If you’re writing a paper, consider citing broader scholarly works that contextualize al-Tabari’s methodology or the period he covers in Volume 6. Examples:
Volume 6 focuses entirely on the Prophet's life in Mecca, a period characterized by intense theological opposition and the gradual establishment of the Islamic message.
Explain the wider controversy surrounding the "Satanic Verses." Provide context on .
: The narrative directly contradicts the foundational Islamic doctrine of Ismah (prophetic infallibility in conveying divine revelation). The Quran itself states in Surah An-Najm (53:3–4) that the Prophet "does not speak from his own inclination. It is not but a revelation revealed." al tabari volume 6 page 111
Al-Tabari records that the Prophet stated, "I have fabricated things against God and have imputed to Him words which He has not spoken." Following this, Surah al-Hajj (22:52) was revealed to comfort him, stating that Satan routinely tries to interfere with the recitations of all prophets, but God repeals Satan's suggestions. Historiographical Nature of Al-Tabari's Work
The account details Gabriel confronting Muhammad, saying he recited words not sent by God, to which Muhammad replies that he fabricated words against God, as noted in the Facebook source and analyzed in historical studies. Debate on Prophet Muhammad's Encounter with Angel or Satan
While reciting Surah an-Najm near the Kaaba, the text states that Satan cast two phrases onto his tongue: If you’re writing a paper, consider citing broader
The detailed accounts provided by al-Tabari, such as those found on , have had a lasting impact on Islamic historiography. His work serves as a fundamental reference for scholars and historians, offering a rich source of information on early Islamic history. Moreover, al-Tabari's balanced approach to recording events, which includes diverse perspectives and rationales behind significant decisions, has been a model for subsequent historians.
: While reciting, Satan allegedly "cast upon his tongue" words praising three pagan goddesses (al-Lat, al-Uzza, and Manat) as "high-flying cranes" whose intercession is desired.
Volume 6 of al-Tabari's history covers a pivotal period in Islamic history. Without the specific details on page 111, one can infer that this section likely discusses significant events, personalities, or theological debates characteristic of the era. Al-Tabari's method of presenting multiple accounts of events allows readers to engage with diverse viewpoints and traditions. their policies apply.
Al-Tabari’s methodology was to record reports without necessarily validating them, leaving the analysis to the reader. This included recording the controversial alongside the accepted, which is why the account appears in his History . Summary of the Event Description Volume/Page Volume VI, Page 111 Subject The "Satanic Verses" Incident Key Narrative Muhammad's confession of uttering false verses. Key Quote "I have fabricated things against God..." Context Reconciliation attempt with Quraysh (Mecca).
This public link is valid for 7 days and shares a thread, including any personal information you added. This link or copies made by others cannot be deleted. If you share with third parties, their policies apply. Can’t copy the link right now. Try again later. The History of al-Ṭabarī Vol. 6: Muḥammad at Mecca
I should offer to help them locate the text if they can provide more details, like the exact topic discussed on page 111, or suggest scholarly articles and books that reference that volume. Maybe recommend works like "Al-Tabari's Tarikh" by Fred Donner or other critical studies. Also, suggest they check academic databases for papers that cite al-Tabari, Volume 6.
Volume 6, page 111 of al-Ṭabarī's History remains a landmark in the study of early Islam. It presents a stark example of the complex, often challenging, historical reports that exist within traditional Islamic literature concerning the Meccan period and the challenges faced by the Prophet Muhammad.